
While the First World War was being fought overseas in Europe, Winnipeg was transforming politically and economically. Jim Blanchard’s
Winnipeg’s Great War: A City Comes of Age explores the contributions made by Winnipeggers and the effects the war had on the city and the people within it.
We had to read the book as part of our journalism class and while it isn't a book I would generally pick up in my own time, I ended up really enjoying the book. Blanchard wrote an informative and interesting book, which provides a local perspective of the events that occurred during the First World War and shows how the war ultimately changed the course of the city’s history. As a reader I was able to identify with the places, the names, the dates and felt a personal connection to the story.
There is a lot of information—dates, names and quotes—in Blanchard’s book. While it makes for a detailed account of the war from Winnipeg’s perspective, the details sometimes felt excessive. At certain points I would question why the name of a specific person or a list of numbers was important to. I do, however, understand that
Winnipeg’s Great War is a historical account and names and numbers are crucial.
Certain parts of the book had a greater effect than others, particularly the personal stories of soldiers who lost their lives. The story of the Waugh family, which is weaved throughout Winnipeg's Great War and eventually concludes the book, offered a personal story to the greater issue and put a face to the thousands of soldiers who lost their lives in the war.
The most obvious thing journalists can learn from this book is the importance of collecting information, facts, dates and names and being able to piece these together to not only make a cohesive, but engaging book. I found it inspiring when Blanchard said he really didn't know much about the First World War when he began his research for the book.
I also learnt that if I had graduated CreComm in 1914, there would have been many more publications and job opportunities for me.
In a lot of ways, Blanchard's book is similar to
Hiroshima by John Hersey that we read recently in class. Both explore the effects war had on two different cities, however Blanchard takes a more academic and factual approach than Hersey.
Hiroshima is told entirely through people's first-hand account and the details and facts are made known through these stories.
Winnipeg's Great War has personal stories too, but they are weaved through lengthy historical accounts of events that happened in the city.
Being able to talk to Blanchard after reading his work and listening to the process he went through to complete it somewhat changes my perspective of the book. It's interesting to know where people started. In Blanchard's case, he really knew very little about the Great War and it goes to show that if anyone puts the time and effort into the research writing a history book is possible.